Every week I run through the best and worst bits of the week on Emmerdale. Tell me your faves and fails in the comments! This week, Cain considered murdering Joe with a hammer and Liv turned back to booze.
Breaking the Enigma
The biggest mystery in Emmerdale village is not how many bedrooms the Woolpack has, but – who is Graham Foster and what is his past? Graham achieved the near impossible this week and took down Cain Dingle before he had the chance to murder Joe, Dexter-style, and then we had a few more hints about his past. The Graham and Joe dynamic is captivating, leaving us with just enough secrets and mysteries about their past together to keep it interesting. Actor Andrew Scarborough keeps Graham quiet and unassuming until it really matters, using careful – sometimes menacing – words when actions aren’t enough. We’re set to learn more about Graham soon, but hopefully in future he will find a more present role in the village too.
It was great news this week as Jessie finally moved into Emmerdale village and it looks like we will soon meet her son too. Jessie brings a fun new energy to the village and I’m interested to see what storylines await her, whether she will continue to be such a good laugh or if something serious is round the corner. I think her and Marlon could be a lovely match but she seems adamantly against that – and I wonder too if it would break that nice dynamic between them if things progressed. There are lots of unanswered questions about Jessie and I’m looking forward to see her more fully integrated in the village.
Everyone Knows Dave!
Comedy can be so hit and miss especially in soaps, but thank goodness for Marlon’s midweek and improvised party which brought so many laughs. We’re used to Marlon and Paddy providing most of the giggles in the village but this week it was a surprise stranger that was such a highlight. Paddy took Marlon’s desperate pleas very seriously and invited a complete random to Marlon’s house and his reaction was genuinely laugh-out-loud brilliant. Poor Dave looked a bit bewildered too and it was all the more funny considering we often see village unknowns in the background of parties, but here it was used for classic comic effect. Great scene.
Out of Character?
Lisa, matriarch of the Dingles has seen as much crime and bad behaviour in her family as she has eaten rabbit pies. But after her near-death experience she became almost unrecognisable (for a few episodes at least). A health scare is bound to make someone reassess but it felt jarring for Lisa to take such a harsh un-Dingle stance after everything that family has done, covered up and protected – especially when she’s housing a convicted sex offender too! Surely the Lisa we know and love would have recognised how devastating prison would be and found a better method of punishment, one that teaches consequence rather than the heavy hand of the law?
The Cringe Factor
Surprisingly there are elements I like about the Laurel/Bob/Brenda plot, but this week was a showcase of the aspects that are really letting the story down. These are all characters who should be sympathetic and in the midst of a painful situation, but each scenario at the moment feels childish and contrived. As Bob and Laurel tried to stay away from each other, this week they found themselves in a silly scenario where Laurel got glue down herself and needed help undressing. Bob was on hand and it all got awkward when she was stood there in a vest. A vest! It was meant to be highly charged but the reality was embarrassing to watch – surely there’s a better way to inject a bit of sexual tension? Meanwhile Brenda continues to privately seethe but surely now eyebrows would be raised? Her running commentary about morality is painfully unsubtle and I find it hard to believe everyone can be so oblivious.