Fave or Fail? (19-23 Aug 2019)

faveorfail

Every week I run through the best and worst bits of the week on Emmerdale. Tell me your faves and fails in the comments! Not one of Emmerdale’s strongest weeks but the best bits came from surprising little storylines.

Faves

Funeral Fractures

MEGA - Emmerdale_2019-08-23_396p.HDTV.x264-SS.mp4The trying times continued at Tug Ghyll this week as Tracy, Vanessa and Megan tried to organise Frank’s funeral. With many of the village wrongly believing Frank stole the charity money, not many were willing to say they would attend, which devastated Tracy and put her relationship with Vanessa under even more strain. There were some great performances too from Gaynor Faye (Megan) this week as she remained conflicted over her feelings for Frank and struggled with the reminders of losing son Robbie. Frank’s death has provided great material for the three main actresses involved and the injustice of everyone believing Frank to be guilty will provide real satisfaction when the truth comes out. Will we ever be able to look at Kerry in the same way – that’s the question!

Unlikely Friends?

vlcsnap-2019-08-24-20h29m26s883Sometimes the best moments in Emmerdale come from the most unlikely places. This week it was strange yet endearing partnership of Cain and Liam, as Liam went to the garage to get his car fixed. Cain, who isn’t known for his gang of mates, offered Dr C a beer and a surprised Liam accepted (after almost spilling the whole thing). After Cain hurt his hand the two had a funny and awkward chat – the extreme of chalk and cheese. The comic timing was spot on and the scene was made even better when Liam reported back his macho activities to a baffled Bernice and Diane. Will their paths ever cross again? Lets hope so!

Pub Wars

vlcsnap-2019-08-24-20h26m04s328Disaster struck at the Woolpack this week as Charity learnt the pub has dry rot and will be out of action for six weeks. While this hopefully means we’ll get treated to a glossy new makeover inside (the pub hasn’t had a refurb since the Cameron siege), it brought chaos to Charity’s door. First she had to persuade Paddy and Bear to move out, but then the bigger problem was business. Crafty Brenda took advantage of Charity’s misfortune and used her license to sell booze after hours, but this started war and Charity retaliated with a big booze up in the garden. This plot was a whole lot of fun, bringing out Charity’s snark and entertaining personality alongside Brenda’s dry one-liners, as well as giving the scenes a big community feel. The village isn’t the same without the pub, but at least we got some good scenes out of it.

Jacob’s Wellbeing

vlcsnap-2019-08-24-20h27m35s919Jacob had a difficult time this week as his poor GCSE results brought it all home just how much Maya’s grooming had impacted upon his future. As David and his merry band of exes tried to give Jacob some relaxed time in the garden to take his mind off it, they realised Jacob had been trying to write to Maya in prison. Later in the week, Priya’s efforts to comfort Jacob got misconstrued and he was furious at her for being a hypocrite. Thankfully Jacob realised he was in the wrong and perhaps there are glimmers here that he’s noticing how Maya warped his mind. Jacob hasn’t yet had the support he needs to cope with the aftermath of what Maya did to him and after a lacklustre resolution, could this mean we’re moving towards Jacob eventually getting some help?

Fails

Bonus Fails:

  • Paddy’s a funny guy with a great script and good physical comedy with Marlon. The stuttering has got old fast. Combine that with Bear’s illiteracy plot and it’s not a winner
  • So Matty’s storyline is over already? Story resolutions have been a bit iffy lately but this takes the biscuit! All of Matty’s crucial moments happened off screen!

Private School Privilege

vlcsnap-2019-08-24-20h26m30s093There was some dry old posh drama at Home Farm this week as the biggest problem seemed to be the local state primary or a fancy private school. The dilemma! It’s still a hard task to believe Jamie’s really the dad of a five year old little girl and rather than Jamie’s reticence about Millie’s childhood being as privileged as his having nuance, it just feels petty and pathetic. While Kim the panto villain doesn’t work, I’m not sure interfering granny is the best use of her either. Andrea too seems charismatic and could be a great character if only we could see her get out of the mansion. Does anyone really care which school Millie goes to? Perhaps if this were a brief comedy story and not one with endless scenes of Jamie sulking around the house, but this week it just felt like the same old story for Jamie and Kim.

Summer Stinker

Emmerdale - Moira and Nate Sleep Together Whilst Cain Is Away - YouTubeNate and Moira finally gave into “temptation” this week in what has got to be one of Emmerdale’s worst affair storylines in a long time. Yes, worse than Bob and Laurel. Yes, worse than Pete and Priya. A naughty roll in the hay with an alpha male might have earned Emmerdale legions of fans with Cain and Moira doing the dirty, but that story was popular because the actors at the helm had smoking hot chemistry. Nate and Moira are just plain awkward together. This week Emmerdale did their very best to convince us of all that sexy chemistry, lots of close up shots of skin touching, the characters breathlessly staring at each other with gawping mouths, Nate chowing down on Moira’s shoulder, cheap Mills and Boon style barn romping. Laboured is not the word! It seems painfully obvious Nate has an agenda but this is ruining Moira’s character and isn’t convincing in the slightest. Granted, Moira’s got frisky on the farm before, but nothing has felt as forced and clunky as this. Nate’s lines seem purposefully cliché, and maybe we’re supposed to believe Moira would sacrifice her marriage for a personality-free hunk doing his best to recreate her previous farm flings, but nah, not buying it. Nate doesn’t have the charm to pull off this seduction lark, he’s coming across as a creep, and worst than that, Emmerdale has thrown one of their most popular couples (and characters) under a bus for this rubbish.

Scene of the Week (19-23 Aug 2019)

sceneoftheweek.png

s169.png

As tension built in the run up to Frank’s funeral, Tracy made a shocking discovery in his wallet that makes my Scene of the Week as the sisters finally received a clue about Frank’s innocence. As an emotional Tracy started to doubt her belief in Frank, she discovered a receipt for an engagement ring. After collecting Frank’s stuff from Megan, Tracy was moved to discover he kept a photo of her as a young girl in his wallet, proving that even though he wasn’t there for her as a young girl, she was always in his thoughts. This was a beautiful performance by Amy Walsh that really makes you believe in Tracy’s troubled past with her dad. But the ring receipt made her realise Frank was due to propose to Megan and hadn’t jeopardised their future as Megan suspected. As Tracy decided this proved his innocent even more, the question remained – who was the guilty party? And who was lurking in the doorway listening? Kerry of course!

Fave or Fail? (12-16 Aug 2019)

faveorfail

Every week I run through the best and worst bits of the week on Emmerdale. Tell me your faves and fails in the comments! Ellis’s dad Al arrived in the village and had a shady phonecall, and Debbie left for Scotland.

Faves

Call Me Al

vlcsnap-2019-08-17-09h00m52s495Jessie had one hell of a week as no sooner had she lost her job, but her household was rocked by the arrival of Al, Ellis’s father. Al didn’t make a great first impression on the family and Ellis didn’t seem all that keen to repair their bond either. There’s tension already, and Al is not a fan of Billy, but this is great news for the audience as a new character like Al, played charismatically by Michael Wildman, needs a great introduction. What’s even better is that Al seems a bit shady and all signs point to him being revealed as Kim Tate’s new business partner. Al could be just the new villain Emmerdale needs. Bring it on!

Sensitive Souls

vlcsnap-2019-08-17-09h04m14s417One of Emmerdale’s sweetest family units was rocked this week as Samson came home and learnt about Lydia’s tragic past. Sensitive Samson was horrified to learn Lydia had been keeping secrets, and worse, that they’d been kept from him. At the graveyard, Sam tried to talk Samson round in a lovely scene in the place where Alice is buried, and eventually Samson was able to empathise with Lydia’s plight. Realising that Lydia needs support, Samson listened to Sam as he said Alice would want them to be happy, and eventually the family were reunited, ready to plan a wedding. Fingers crossed things go smoothly from now on and we get to see Sam and Lydia made official!

Doug on Pot

vlcsnap-2019-08-17-09h01m33s577The most amusing and bizarre plot of the week was Doug, on pot. Straight laced, garden enthusiast would be the last person you’d expect to smoke a joint, but with Gerry’s stash playing on his mind – and his terrible back – Doug went to surprising measures to cure his pain. As we all know Duncan Preston has a long history of comedic acting so it was great to see this at play, even funnier when his oblivious loved ones have no idea and don’t notice the signs. High Doug was a lot of fun and seeing as he’s already getting the munchies, I’m sure he’ll be sneaking off for another spliff when the opportunity arises!

Goodbye Debbie

vlcsnap-2019-08-17-09h04m59s066Debbie’s exit this week, to cover Charley Webb’s maternity leave, has to be one of the strangest. Her exit potential could have nicely tied into her feud with Cain or hints about Joe, but all that was left aside, as Debbie took over a random garage in Scotland. As you do. Surprisingly I’ve really come to enjoy Debbie lately, as she’s been used in light, comic relief moments or more low key storylines. Debbie’s actually been – dare I say it – sort of fun? Her exit scenes were muted this week, with a lovely scene from Sarah and a slightly OTT reaction from Charity. It was a little hard to care about any emotional response to her leaving when we know she’ll be back, but my only hope is that when they bring Debbie back, they remember to give her a bit more of that dry humour. Maybe she could even smile!

Fails

Slim on Sympathy

vlcsnap-2019-08-17-08h58m53s948When Matty’s toxic masculinity story started I questioned, given his divisive popularity, whether he was the right character to be plunged into a plot where he has to be a real arsehole. This week, I still have my reservations. Matty’s friends showed up again being characteristically vile and Matty laughed along with them. Sure, he looks sheepish from time to time, and eventually he’ll see them for what they are, but is it worth Matty being this smarmy and horrid in the meantime? Watching him swagger and jeer like his unlikeable “mates” just really isn’t very unenjoyable to watch.

The Trouble with Faith

vlcsnap-2019-08-17-08h57m56s682There’s something about Faith this year that’s making her far more irritating than she is entertaining. Perhaps it’s because she’s been overbearing and interfering, rather than the light and shade we’ve had from her in previous years. A character like Faith can be more than just brash and we’ve seen her earn our affections during her mastectomy struggles through her romance with Eric and her family past in the Cain flashback. We’ve also seen a good dose of humour too. This week however we’ve seen more of Faith’s abrasive side as she muscled in at Wishing Well, landed an ill advised kiss on Zak and then outed Bear’s illiteracy secret. The kiss plot seemed like a complete overreaction to what was a brief, grief fuelled peck – and actually her reminiscing scenes with Zak were nicely done – and the cellar debacle felt completely contrived. Was this all just a circus to get her to annoy Charity in her new home? Faith can be great when the balance is right but this week, she lost her warmth.

Scene of the Week (12-16 Aug 2019)

sceneoftheweek.pngs168.png

After losing her job as headteacher, Jessie was in no mood to hear any backlash about her (lack of) involvement in Maya’s inappropriate conduct. With a few drinks down her, Jessie was furious at the accusations and criticism coming from Nicola, especially after learning she was involved in parents complaining, and decided to let rip at the parents in the room and their angelic (or not so) children. This was one of those excruciatingly cringey scenes, and while she was out of line, Jessie also had a point – responsible parenting is not at home in Emmerdale. The criticisms pointed at Jessie could have come straight from social media so the whole scene was sort of meta, and felt like Emmerdale’s way of papering over the plot holes. Jessie’s meltdown caused one hell of a scene. Cringey – yes, but totally entertaining.

Fave or Fail? (5-9 Aug 2019)

faveorfail

Every week I run through the best and worst bits of the week on Emmerdale. Tell me your faves and fails in the comments! Robert learnt he might be facing life in prison and Kerry sunk to new depths.

Faves

Robert’s World Ends

vlcsnap-2019-08-10-11h43m54s596Robert’s life came crashing down around him this week as he was charged with GBH with intent. Just as he and husband Aaron had decided to get their surrogacy plans up and running again, the police came a’knocking, revealing Vic’s rapist Lee had woken from his coma. In tense scenes, the police interviewed Robert revealing the damning evidence against him and Robert unable to stick to his solicitor’s advice, tried to defend himself. All this lead to a charge and a warning that he could be looking at life imprisonment. Robert was floored by this news and Ryan Hawley’s already mastered Robert’s private devastation as he covered up the truth from Aaron and the rest of his family. As Robert tried to put on a brave face, his inevitable fate is a tough watch, especially knowing how much his loved ones will struggle. It’s both a gripping and heart-breaking storyline to watch unfold with impressive performances from Ryan as reality sunk in and it’s going to become even more gut-wrenching as Robert’s future becomes impossible to avoid.

The Fire Fall-out Continues

vlcsnap-2019-08-10-11h47m18s204The Sharmas were at rock bottom this week in the wake of the factory fire. With the dodgy alarm turned off by Rishi, the insurance company were reluctant to give them any sort of pay-out so once again they turned to resident moneybags – Kim Tate – to save the factory. It’s made a nice change to see the Sharmas given a serious storyline that has an impact on all family members and even Manpreet struggled with her guilt and attempted to leave because of it. It’s been a good story that doesn’t just affect a small bubble of characters or one family, but has spiralled out into other characters too. Besides Kerry and Amy’s involvement, Frank’s daughters, the workers are also impacted too and now Kim’s involved it’s helped widen her circle of interactions and given her purpose. Jai has shaped up to be a great character these days and his scenes with Kim were particularly watchable. Both him and Priya have become a lot more likeable lately so their downfall has more emotional investment and we could even see this effect Jai’s relationship with Laurel. Kim’s involvement also has potential, especially as we know she has big plans, and this story has allowed us to see her ruthless businesswoman side, and not the cartoonish gangster she had been written as before.

Grieving Girls

vlcsnap-2019-08-10-11h46m45s755Tracy and Vanessa struggled to cope with their grief in the aftermath of Frank’s shock death this week. At first the pair were divided and then their conflict continued when Tracy was sure of Frank’s innocence in the fire, with Vanessa being more suspicious. As Tracy’s grief manifested in gut-wrenching sobs and emptiness, her sister was more stoic, pained and unable to talk and both actresses did a good job in the spectrum of emotions. Both had believable breakdowns over the smallest things like Frank’s favourite song and Vanessa running out of petrol triggering a explosion of grief and it was a good choice to have them both react in different ways to the same tragedy.

Too Little Too Late

vlcsnap-2019-08-10-11h45m03s674This week Jessie was sent in front of an education board in scenes which looked like the dialogue had been taken straight from Twitter! Not only has Jessie’s job been seen as a bit of a joke (she’s never there!) but her role in the Maya/Jacob storyline was completely ignored. While Jessie should have been taken to task over safe-guarding and had some sort of emotional response to a member of her staff grooming a pupil, Jessie was noticeably absent through the whole story and community reactions were muted. This week Jessie was suspended and finally, finally, it seemed like there was an effort to give Maya’s actions more village-wide impact. It might be too little too late but at least it’s happening now and the scenes were still satisfying. Jacob’s lack of aftermath however is another aspect sorely missing and it’s a wonder if it’ll ever be revisited…

Bonus Faves:

  • Two stand-out scenes that almost made the cut for Scene of the Week was Vanessa’s overdue breakdown of grief with Rhona in her car. A great scene made even more impactful by one of Emmerdale’s most enduring and genuine friendships. And secondly, the unusual partnership of Robert and Jai (with bonus Tip), looking out over the Dales. This was a quiet and effective moment where both characters reflected on the impossible challenges ahead. Characters who rarely cross paths always feels like a treat and this was the same
  • Moses “I told you” in reference to Frank’s death to little Johnny was both hilariously cutting, but perfectly childlike. We need to see more of these two as they grow up together!

Fails

Sinking Lower and Lower

vlcsnap-2019-08-10-11h52m03s427Last week I questioned if Kerry could come back from her charity money theft, which lead to Frank’s death, but after her behaviour this week I’m even less sure. Can we really laugh along with Kerry’s antics knowing the lies she’s telling? It’s one thing to do something desperate to try and look after her family, but this week lying about Frank’s involvement and then going with Tracy to the mortuary was all just a bit too twisted. Even Amy pointed out that she seemed to enjoy the attention and at times it felt like she was right. Kerry’s remorse didn’t seem strong enough and I’m not sure a few tears can repair her likeability in the eyes of the audience. There are times though that I’ve almost felt she’s so unlikeable that perhaps they should go the whole way and make her a complete villain. Whatever the case, Amy needs to distance herself fast before she becomes Emmerdale’s second most hated.

Scene of the Week (5-9 Aug 2019)

sceneoftheweek.png

s167.png

We knew it was bad as soon as Chas said “He’s innocent, he’s not going anywhere” and the scene cut to a very anxious looking Robert down at the police station, but the ground falling away under Robert’s feet was a stand-out moment of the week. Even after his optimistic solicitor gave him hope, Robert must have known his luck had run out, but the final blow came when the solicitor revealed the police wanted to charge him not with GBH, but with GBH with intent. As Rob scrambled to work out what this meant, the solicitor gave him the crushing news that this charge could mean a life sentence. Viewers know with Ryan Hawley leaving that Robert’s sentence would likely be a long once, but this didn’t lessen the impact of the scene. In a split second, Ryan’s impressive performance showed Robert’s complete devastation with his whole world changing in an instant and it was a great scene.