Fave or Fail? (23-27 Dec 2019)

faveorfail

Every week I run through the best and worst bits of the week on Emmerdale. Tell me your faves and fails in the comments! It was Christmas week and as the villagers indulged in some festive fun, some smiles didn’t last for long.

Faves

Dinner Drama

vlcsnap-2019-12-28-15h02m06s682There was real traditional Christmas Day soapy goodness at Home Farm this year and it all kicked off in their beautifully decorated house. With Marlon doing the catering there was a “classic” Emmerdale feel with Kim displaying her wealth and power and there was an enjoyable amount of humour in this set up. Of course, Marlon was mainly there to see Graham’s destructive behaviour firsthand, but it made an interesting change to see a posh Christmas rather than just the Dingle knees up. Graham managed to put a grenade in proceedings by revealing he’d slept with Andrea but it was good that Emmerdale subverted expectations and kept Jamie as Millie’s father while still managing to tear the family apart with the revelations. I’m glad we get to keep Granny Kim at least! As the fall out rumbled on it helped make the family and the individuals more engaging to watch, with Jamie cycling through rage and grief and Andrea struggling to cling on. The magic has finally clicked into place for Kim and the last few months have ironed out all her teething problems. As we build to Graham’s exit though, I wonder if there’s enough motive in the Tate household to make Graham’s death feel organic rather than contrived if this continues over many more weeks.

Doorstep Delivery

vlcsnap-2019-12-28-15h01m21s517There was an unwelcome delivery at Farrer’s Barn on Christmas Day as Jacob discovered a baby on the doorstep. As the family stared at the bundle confused, they found a note, revealing the little boy to be Maya’s. As the panic and realisation set in, they tried to keep the baby secret, only contacted Liam when they realised they needed a DNA test. With David vowing to be the baby’s father (or pretend) whatever happens, both him and Leyla deluded themselves with the idea that this could protect Jacob from any more trauma. The baby story continues to be an unexpected direction for the story to take and is an interesting way of exploring Jacob’s long term recovery and bringing a new challenge for the entire family. This week’s scenes were gripping and well written and was even an interesting way of introducing Maya’s mum and building on Liam and Leyla’s relationship.

Hospital Festivities

vlcsnap-2019-12-28-14h59m04s494Poor Noah had a miserable Christmas, stuck in hospital after he was found in the woods, unconscious after his drug taking. Luckily he was on the road to recovery by the big day and Charity, Vanessa, Tracy and the kids rallied round his hospital bedside to give him some festive cheer. There were games and presents and sparkly clothing, but most of all, it was the touching scenes between mother and son that were the highlight. While this wasn’t a conventional family gathering at Christmas, it made a nice change to see a slightly unusual celebration in the episode. Sarah covered up her bad behaviour and continued to be pretty insufferable, but perhaps it’ll be worth it for Granny Charity’s reaction in the end!

Fails

Rhona’s Rage

vlcsnap-2019-12-28-14h57m03s095There was something particularly unlikeable about Rhona during Christmas week. Since her menopause story some viewers have taken objection to her mood swings and short temper, but I can’t help but feel the character has lost her way a little in recent months. This week saw her continue to lie to Marlon about moving away with Leo and then, once again, changing her mind on Graham, only to change it back again. I’m finding their relationship all a bit tiresome now. Then when Marlon found out the truth about Rhona’s plans to move, the exes exploded at each other in a way that brought out the worst sides in both of them – let’s face it, neither of them have made good romantic choices. Will Graham’s exit help to return Rhona to a more likeable character again?

Public Enemy No.1

vlcsnap-2019-12-28-14h58m11s001In the run up to Christmas Emmerdale released a very glossy new trailer teasing Graham’s grisly murder and a number of suspects who will be lining up to end his days. However, with a whodunnit plot comes ferocious rivalries and exacerbated grudges, all so there are a few more murder suspects in the line-up. This week we saw evidence of that as Charity lashed out at Graham after Noah’s drug taking ended up with him in hospital and Marlon was ready to fight – and lose. There’s nothing out of character about impulsive and emotional reactions making characters threaten and want a war with Graham, but no one surely believes Charity and Marlon capable of actual murder? Their responses to Graham this week felt more like a clunky suspect set up and over-blown, rather than a believable desire to want to murder the man! Here’s hoping there isn’t too much more of this as we build to his demise.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s